I've never been a heavy lifter. I've lifted weights for years (and years and years), but I was always more into high reps and lighter weights, hoping for more definition rather than bulk.
But as I got into the healthy longevity thing, I began to wonder whether I had it quite right. You can't pick up a book or have a discussion about healthspan without being bombarded by the lift heavy mantra.
As I understand it, and I believe it, building and maintaining muscle while we're still young enough to do so is a key part of staying strong, capable, and resilient as we get older.
So, starting six months ago, I did just that. I started lifting heavier. My 35-pound dumbbell presses became 65s. My 40-pound Romanian deadlifts became 130.
It's worked. I feel stronger, and thanks to some careful workout design with AI, I've also avoided the bulking up I didn't want.
But then I started noticing something.
As I've engaged in more conversations with others in the healthspan world, I've begun to realize just how much of the discussion revolves around heavy lifting. A lot.
At a dinner party recently with some fellow healthspan enthusiasts, I was finally able to participate in a discussion about how much everyone was lifting, pulling, pushing, and thrusting.
But then it hit me. When it came to weight training and fitness, that was pretty much all we were talking about.
It felt like we were all rushing toward the new hot, sexy thing. Surely my hours of endurance training, yoga, and cardio weren't all for naught? (In fairness, the longevity crowd seems pretty enthusiastic about Zone 2 cardio and HIIT workouts too.)
So I've been pleased to come across a couple of recent articles that broaden the discussion.
The first, about a study published in the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism, reminds us that having more muscle isn't the whole story when it comes to metabolic health.
Researchers examining nearly 60,000 adults found that where we carry fat, particularly visceral fat around our internal organs, matters enormously. Simply having more lean mass wasn't a guarantee of better metabolic health.
It doesn't mean we shouldn't build muscle. It means that muscle alone isn't a magic shield against the consequences of excess fat.
And there's another study I recently shared in Worth Reading, suggesting that balance and agility may be particularly important predictors of longevity.
Neither study makes the case against lifting heavy. And I'm certainly not giving it up. I'm actually loving my experiment with it.
But they've reminded me that the goal isn't to win the dinner-party competition over who can lift the most.
It's to stay strong, fit, nimble, and healthy enough to keep doing the things I love.
And that requires more than a heavier dumbbell.